Switch to an accessible version of this website which is easier to read. (requires cookies)

Labour should listen to our NHS doctors

October 26, 2019 10:02 AM
By Liberal Democrats
Originally published by UK Liberal Democrats

medics

The NHS is in crisis, but Labour care more about theoretical restructures than listening to doctors and nurses about what it really needs: funding for front line-services, not another reorganisation.

Yesterday, Labour's Shadow Health Secretary, Jonathon Ashworth tabled an amendment to the Queen's speech calling for the Health and Social Care Act 2012 to be repealed. We refused to back it, and it lost.

Make no mistake: this dangerous amendment was driven by empty ideology, just like Labour's stance on Brexit. The disruption the amendment would have caused would have been catastrophic for the NHS. Most importantly, the NHS did not want it.

As we all know, the NHS is dependant on the hard work and dedication of staff from countries across the EU, and the unnecessary chaos Brexit is causes is taking vital focus and resources away from improving our public services.

We're clear: the only way to save the NHS is to stop Brexit.

Labour's NHS amendment is just a taste of what could happen to the NHS in the hands of the Labour government, who value ideology over the voices of NHS staff.

Instead, Sarah Woollaston MP, Chair of the Health and Social Care Committee pointed out that politicians should listen to NHS staff to hear how the current system can be approved, rather causing chaos by tearing the NHS apart:

Sarah Wollaston MP @sarahwollaston

1. Instead of attacking @LibDems for refusing to back @UKLabour plans for a disruptive & unwanted NHS reorganisation, it's time for Mr Corbyn to listen to what the people who work in & lead the NHS are asking for https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/BM1917-NHS-recommendations-Government-Parliament-for-an-NHS-Bill.pdf

654 people are talking about this

She highlighted that Labour's amendment completely ignores the extremely hard work that staff from across the NHS have put in to create a set of expert recommendations to Parliament on what would actually improve the service:

Sarah Wollaston MP @sarahwollaston

1. Instead of attacking @LibDems for refusing to back @UKLabour plans for a disruptive & unwanted NHS reorganisation, it's time for Mr Corbyn to listen to what the people who work in & lead the NHS are asking for https://www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/BM1917-NHS-recommendations-Government-Parliament-for-an-NHS-Bill.pdf

Sarah Wollaston MP @sarahwollaston

2. The NHS has made recommendations to Parliament & to Govt on the legislative changes it needs, after an extensive consultation & having worked alongside the cross party @CommonsHealth select committee which also took evidence & reported https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmhealth/2000/200002.htm

80 people are talking about this
Luciana Berger @lucianaberger

This is the biggest load of nonsense.

There were elements I could support in the @UKLabour Regret motion (which doesn't do more than... regret).

But I can't support repealing (rather than amending)the Act, prompting a top-down NHS reorganisation which no one in the NHS wants. https://twitter.com/jeremycorbyn/status/1187082413194829831

Jeremy Corbyn @jeremycorbyn

The Tories just voted against Labour's motion to safeguard our NHS from being sold off to US corporations in a Johnson-Trump trade deal. And the @LibDems, who voted to privatise the NHS when in coalition, abstained.

Labour built the NHS and we're the only party that can save it.

Luciana Berger @lucianaberger

It would also cost billions of pounds. The Labour Party used to be against these NHS reorganisations.

91 people are talking about this

Sarah Wollaston MP @sarahwollaston

3. @UKLabour plans are ideologically driven & would not be welcomed by the NHS. They would cause major disruption when the main asks can be achieved in the ways they have set out in their report. This has widespread support from their workforce & those working alongside them

Sarah Wollaston MP @sarahwollaston

Here are the opening key asks from the NHS on future legislation. All political parties should be listening to what the people who lead and work in our NHS have to say, including @UKLabour . These include scrapping section75. Evidence matters more than rigid ideology

View image on Twitter
141 people are talking about this

This is why we would prioritise spending for vital front-line services, not another reorganisation. As the original pioneers of the health service, Liberals have always made providing health care for all a top priority. Let's work with the NHS, not against it.

But first of all, we must stop Brexit. This is the only way to save the NHS.